A colleague is not performing dilated examinations when it is clinically required. What do you do?

In each issue, Acuity poses a topical question on a tricky scenario to a panel of members.

Share options

I would start by running an assessment and audit of the risk to previous patients who may not have been dilated, with potential recall and re-examination. I would also consider how to support the education and training of this colleague.

Challenging a colleague on competency can present some potentially uncomfortable conversations. We have regular optometry meetings, and this would be a good opportunity to have “When to dilate?” as a discussion point. Among our team, we try to get agreement as to how to deal with similar clinical presentations: “So we are agreed, if such and such presents, we are all going to do this.”

But the nettle needs to be grasped and someone needs to have a supportive discussion with this colleague about why they do not dilate, as the consequences to patient safety are so serious. From this, should they agree to change their clinical decision-making and they undergo further accredited and appropriate training, I would suggest a period of supervision then a further three-month review.

However, if they refuse to accept the clinical necessity of dilation, then I’d argue whether they should be practising at all.

Stuart Ingleby MCOptom Practice Director, Specsavers Blackburn


Login Required

Not yet a member of the College?

Start enjoying the benefits of College membership today. Take a look at what the College can offer you and view our membership categories and rates.