The World Health Organization has stated that climate change affects the social and environmental determinants of health [7] and the Lancet Commission on Global Eye Health has identified eye health as essential to achieving the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals [8]. The Lancet Commission states that global health care is estimated to contribute to approximately 5% of all greenhouse gas emissions. As eye care is a high volume health service, it is a substantial contributor to health care greenhouse gas emissions and its contribution is likely to rise with ageing populations [8].
The European Council of Optometry and Optics (ECOO) summarises these relationships [9] as follows:
- climate change is likely to increase the incidence of some eye diseases such as trachoma infections, vitamin A deficiency, cataracts, severe allergic eye disease, glaucoma and eye injuries
- in some places delivery of eye care will be affected because of the increased frequency of extreme weather events
- healthcare is a major consumer of resources and emitter of greenhouse gas emissions
- the optical business model is predicated on promoting consumption of goods – encouraging patients to regularly replace their spectacles, with all the consequences that has in terms of manufacturing, packaging, use of resources and waste management
- plastic waste is a particular problem in the optical sector – eg packaging, dummy lenses, old frames and lenses and contact lenses
Primary and secondary eye care also contribute to carbon levels via manufacturing, energy use and patient travel.
One study by the Centre for Sustainable Healthcare has estimated the average carbon footprint of an individual NHS sight test is 5.27 kg of carbon dioxide equivalent1 [10]. The sight test greenhouse gas emissions were broken down as 69% from travel, 14% from energy, 11% from procurement, 5% from waste and 1% from water. If this estimate is applied to the UK as a whole, with over 15 million nationally-funded sight tests carried out across the UK each year, this would add up to over 79,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent from nationally-funded sight tests alone.
Similarly, a study in 2013 estimated that a single cataract operation in the UK generated 181.8kg of carbon dioxide equivalent [11]. Building and energy use accounted for 36%, procurement 54% (of which medical equipment accounted for 33%) and travel 10%. While both of these studies are small and the evidence base in eye care is limited, they indicate the potential impact of eye care on greenhouse gas emissions.
The benefits of sight tests and other eye care interventions are crucial to improving vision, eye health and wider health outcomes for individuals, however it is still important to minimise as much as possible the environmental impact of care – without compromising patient safety, quality of care or patient outcomes.
1 A carbon dioxide equivalent (CO₂e) is a measure that is used to standardise the climate effects of different greenhouse gases.